
I Should Have Seen You
Studio level clarity. Sweet female vocals lead. instrumental loop, timpani, viola, heartbreak, poignant, snare drum, expressive percussion, yearning, guitar bass, introspection, woodwinds, , lush passion, strings, regret, sad violin, emotional delivery, sorrow, elegant, lonely, choral harmonies, clarity, singer/songwriter, soulful piano, dynamic shifts, string instruments, crescendos, quartet, percussion, tears

I Should Have Seen You
Studio level clarity. Sweet female vocals lead. instrumental loop, timpani, viola, heartbreak, poignant, snare drum, expressive percussion, yearning, guitar bass, introspection, woodwinds, , lush passion, strings, regret, sad violin, emotional delivery, sorrow, elegant, lonely, choral harmonies, clarity, singer/songwriter, soulful piano, dynamic shifts, string instruments, crescendos, quartet, percussion, tears
Lyrics
(Verse 1)
I told you that you’re normal
Smiled soft and tried to soothe
But behind your eyes was thunder,
And I missed the storm in you.
I painted your pain in my colors
I thought we were fine, we were whole
But I missed the cracks that bled through
Two girls grasping control
(Pre-Chorus)
You needed more than comfort,
More than borrowed light,
You needed someone who could say,
"Something here’s not right."
(Chorus)
I should have seen you bleeding in the quiet,
Shattering where no one else could see.
I should have known to listen, not deny it—
But I was too lost in the brokenness in me.
We called it “normal,” thought it made us strong,
But we were just surviving,
In a life that was all wrong.
(Verse 2)
Then came the days I shattered—
Still, they told me, “You’re okay.”
I wore the smile they needed,
While inside I slipped away.
You needed truth, and I repeated
The same lie they gave to me—
That pain just means we're growing,
Ignored the rot that laid beneath
(Pre-Chorus)
I didn't know I'd failed you,
Till I felt alone,
I just thought if we powered through,
We’d both find our way home.
(Chorus)
I should have seen you, bleeding in the quiet,
Breaking in the places no one else could see.
I should have known to hear you, not deny it—
But I was too lost in the brokenness in me.
We called it “normal,” thought it made us strong,
But we were just surviving,
In a life that was all wrong.
(Bridge – spoken/sung softly)
But years have passed and now I ache
For all the words I left unsaid
For the guidance I didn’t give
For the life you could have led.
(Final Chorus – full voice)
I see you now, your heart in all its grieving,
I see the war you fought behind your smile.
And if you still need someone who’s believing—
I’m here, and I’ll walk with you a thousand miles.
We can be broken, not just raw and real,
And maybe it’s when we can say it
That our hearts could mend and truly heal.
