I’m staring at my phone again

Analyzing every "lol" you send

It’s 2:00 AM, I should be asleep

But I’m counting all the secrets that we keep

You’re just my best friend, that’s the rule

Anything else would be un-cool

But then you laughed and caught my eye

And I forgot my practiced alibi

The room got quiet, the air got thin

And now the walls are caving in!

I said I didn’t, I swore I wouldn’t

I told my heart it absolutely shouldn’t

But the way you’re looking in that faded crew

Is making all my "no’s" feel less than true

I’m caught in the middle, stuck in the "who knew?"

Yeah, maybe I do!

(Whoa-oh, maybe I do!)

We’re sitting in your driveway now

I’m trying to remember how to breathe out loud

You’re talking ‘bout some band I’ve never heard

But I’m hung up on every single word

I’m messy-haired and over-thinking

While the ship I’m steering is slowly sinking

‘Cause when you reached to change the song

I almost reached for you—was I wrong?

The streetlights flicker, the sky is blue

And I’m terrified of what is true!

I said I didn’t, I swore I wouldn’t

I told my heart it absolutely shouldn’t

But the way you’re looking in that faded crew

Is making all my "no’s" feel less than true

I’m caught in the middle, stuck in the "who knew?"

Yeah, maybe I do!

I could play it safe and just stay quiet

Keep the peace and start a riot

In my head, in my chest

But I’m tired of being second-best to my own pride

Yeah, I’m done trying to hide!

I said I didn’t, I swore I wouldn’t

I told my heart it absolutely shouldn’t

But the way you’re looking in that faded crew

Is making all my "no’s" feel less than true

I’m caught in the middle, stuck in the "who knew?"

Yeah, maybe I do!

Yeah, maybe I do...

(Maybe I do!)

Just a little bit...

(Maybe I do!)

I think I really do